Why muscle gains slow down and how to keep progressing
If you had a transformation contest and said you put on 2 kg of muscle in two years, people would tell you to get a new trainer. Yet that is a great result for an experienced natural lifter. In this conversation, sports scientist and natural pro bodybuilder Eric Helms explains why progress slows, why you almost never hit a true genetic limit and what you can do to keep improving without wrecking your life.
Why muscle gains slow down
Your newbie gains cannot be repeated. The more muscle you build, the less you can build on top of it, and large meta analyses confirm this diminishing return.
Helms uses powerlifting data. Lifters who start competing already have some training behind them. In their first year or so, they raise their total by about 10 percent on average, with a range of roughly 7 to 12 percent. Then it takes about 10 years to gain that much again. A lifter who totals 450 kg may reach 500 kg and then 550 kg after a decade. That is a rude awakening for anyone who believes they will be a world champion in five years.
The same pattern appears with volume. Doing 10 sets per muscle per week gives more than twice the gains of 4 sets. To repeat that jump you need to triple your volume again.
You do not have one genetic limit
Baselines differ between people, but relative gains are surprisingly similar. Men and women start from different levels, yet multiple meta analyses show similar percentage increases in strength and muscle. A study comparing people of African and European ancestry also found different starting points but similar relative adaptations.
Variation in short studies can mislead. In a classic 12 week trial of almost 1,000 untrained people, strength gains ranged from a few percent to 250 percent, and muscle growth from none to 59 percent. Helms warns that this does not prove fixed genetics, because sleep, stress and environment can change from one block to the next.
Because gains diminish at every dose, you have as many ceilings as you have sustainable training doses. A true plateau feels like walking through mud with an alligator behind you. Two months of abrupt stalling is not your natural limit.
What testosterone and steroids really change
A dose of 600 mg of testosterone per week is far above clinical replacement, and it works more like a second puberty. It raises the baseline of what you can build. People who stop anabolic drugs lose a lot of muscle even if they keep training. Differences in testosterone within the normal range explain only about a kilogram of lean mass, so mechanical loading remains the main driver. Helms also stresses that exogenous testosterone can shut down natural production, and that whether past use gives a lasting advantage through myonuclei is still an open question.
How to train for more
Choose your volume wisely
From a return on investment view, 10 to 20 sets per muscle per week is appropriate for almost everyone, and 6 to 8 sets still works well and exceeds activity guidelines. Helms trains up to 30 sets per muscle because he competes. He raised volume gradually over about three years and still developed elbow tendinopathy and quadriceps tendinitis.
Train close enough to failure
You do not always need failure. Look for a slowing of rep speed. A loss of about 20 percent in velocity, or roughly 3 to 4 reps in reserve, makes a set productive. In a study of trained lifters, going to failure on leg press and leg extension did not grow quads noticeably more than stopping one or two reps short. With heavy loads, failure matters even less.
Pick exercises and rep ranges
Include heavy work around your 8 to 10RM, in sets of 4 to 6 so that reps stay in the tank. Use isolation exercises for size, since muscle responds well from 8 to 25 reps. If your elbows complain, use sets of 15 instead of heavy triceps work.
Save time
Superset opposing muscles, use drop sets and rest pause, or split training into two short sessions. Supersets feel 10 to 20 percent harder but bring similar results. Build up before you try them and track whether performance drops. The same constraints approach works whether you are a competitor or someone with only two hours a week to train, because you start from your time and your goals.
Track what you do
Keep a log so you can tell when a new strategy works. If a superset drops your next set far below normal, rest longer or change the pairing. Do not become a victim of the latest fad.
Conclusion
Progress slows because returns diminish, not because you are done. Choose a dose you can sustain, train close to failure, track your results and compare yourself to yourself. A little goes a long way when you keep it up for a lifetime.
Knowledge offered by Simon Hill
Products mentioned
A comprehensive daily supplement formula positioned as an all in one blend of vitamins, minerals, and additional compounds.
Membership that includes extensive lab testing (100+ biomarkers) and insights from clinicians to help interpret results.
Electrolyte drink mix with 500mg sodium, 100mg potassium, and 30mg magnesium per serving, with no artificial ingredients or food dye.
A book series by strength and physique researcher Eric Helms that explains how to prioritize training, nutrition and recovery decisions for muscle growth.